• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
KingSpry Logo

King, Spry, Herman, Freund & Faul, LLC.

Attorneys & Counselors

  • 610-332-0390
  • Pay My Bill (Retainer Only)
  • Pay My Bill (All Other Invoices)
  • About
    • About Us
    • Commitment to the Community
    • Firm History
    • Career Opportunities At KingSpry
    • Directions
  • Practices
    • Adoption / ART Law
    • Affordable Housing Law
    • Bankruptcy Law
    • Business Law
    • Education Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Planning / Administration
    • Family Law
    • Investigations and Compliance Services
    • Litigation
    • Local Taxation and Assessment
    • Municipal Law
    • Public Finance
    • Real Estate Law
    • Special Education Law
  • Team
  • Greyfriars
  • News
    • News
    • Articles
  • Podcasts
    • Landmarks Podcasts
    • Legal Lunch Room Podcasts
  • Review
  • Contact

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Upholds Doctrine of Exclusivity in Workers’ Compensation Cases

Posted on July 18th, 2023
by Avery E. Smith

On April 19, 2023, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued a significant decision, which enforced the Pennsylvania Workers’ Compensation Act’s Exclusivity provision.

In its opinion, the court addressed employers’ immunity in personal injury civil litigation matters.  KingSpry’s Employment Law Chair, Avery E. Smith, details the Court’s opinion in Franczyk v. The Home Depot, Inc.

Case Details

While working at Home Depot, Plaintiff, Lindsay Franczyk, was bitten by a customer’s dog. Franczyk reported the incident to her supervisors, who allegedly barred her from contacting the dog owner or any other witnesses.

After investigation, the supervisors were unable to obtain contact information for the customer or the dog. As a result of the dog bite, Franczyk developed cubital tunnel syndrome, which required surgery. Following a workers’ compensation claim, Franczyk received benefits.  

Later, Franczyk sued Home Depot and her supervisors, asserting that their acts and omissions denied her the opportunity to file a third-party suit against the dog owner. She alleged that the failure to adequately investigate the incident and obtain contact information prevented her from pursuing a claim.

Home Depot claimed immunity under the Pennsylvania Workers’ Compensation Act’s (“WCA”) exclusivity provision, however, the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas denied its motion and ruled in favor of Franczyk. The Home Depot appealed.

What was the Issue?

On appeal, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reviewed whether an employee who suffers a workplace injury attributable to a non-employer third party is precluded by the Exclusivity provision from bringing a tort claim against the employer.

What was the Answer?

The Court succinctly responded to this question, finding that the worker’s compensation system is a compromise that, in exchange for a no-fault insurance system, grants employers immunity from tort liability for workplace injuries. Therefore, Franczyk could not sue Home Deport for allegedly failing to investigate the incident as she had already received workers’ compensation benefits.

What is the Exclusivity Provision?

The WCA Exclusivity provision provides: “liability of an employer under this act shall be exclusive and in place of any and all other liability to such employees … entitled to damages in any action at law or otherwise on account of any injury or death…”

In simple terms, employees cannot sue an employer for a work-related injury as long as they are receiving benefits from workers’ compensation. The PA Supreme Court’s decision upheld this principle.

Takeaways for Employers

The decision in Franczyk affirms the enforcement of the Exclusivity provision of WCA. This decision protects employers from being forced to defend against lawsuits where an employee makes allegations against them for failing to investigate workplace injury and impeding their ability to recover against third-party tortfeasors.

KingSpry’s Employment Law attorneys assist employers of all sizes to proactively and responsibly manage their employment and human resources needs. If you have questions about Workers’ Compensation or employment needs, click here to contact a member of our employment group.

Primary Sidebar

Contact Us

Contacting any of the attorneys at KingSpry by e-mail or other means does not create an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, you should not send confidential information through this form or by e-mail. Unless and until you speak with one of our attorneys and an attorney-client relationship is formally established by that attorney's agreement to represent you, you should not send us confidential information. If you are not currently a client of King, Spry, Herman, Freund & Faul, LLC, your e-mail is not considered confidential.

From Our Articles

A green stylized logo with the letters "K" and "S" combined within a green square. The "K," formed by abstract shapes, is to the left while the conventional "S" on the right balances it perfectly. Ideal for your homepage branding.

Pennsylvania’s Act 87 of 2026: Expanded Mandated Reporting Obligations

November 20, 2026

Pennsylvania’s Child Protective Services Law (CPSL) continues to evolve in response to emerging concerns

A green stylized logo with the letters "K" and "S" combined within a green square. The "K," formed by abstract shapes, is to the left while the conventional "S" on the right balances it perfectly. Ideal for your homepage branding.

Welcome News for PA Government & Agencies: Act 114 Prohibits Certain Terms in Procurement Contracts

November 18, 2026

On October 22, 2026, Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro signed Act 114 of 2026 into law, prohibiting certain

Footer

King Spry White Logo

Quick Link

About KingSpry Commitment to the Community Firm History Career Opportunities at KingSpry Directions

Practice Areas

Adoption / ART Law Affordable Housing Law Bankruptcy Law Business Law Education Law Employment Law Estate Planning / Administration Family Law
Investigations and Compliance Services Litigation Local Taxation and Assessment Municipal Law Public Finance Real Estate Law Special Education Law

Contact

phone

610-332-0390

email

contact@kingspry.com

location

1 West Broad Street. Suite 700 Bethlehem, PA 18018

location

American Heritage Building. 4400 Walbert Avenue Allentown, PA 18104

Facebook Youtube LinkedIn

Pay My Bill (Retainer Only) Pay My Bill (All Other Invoices)

Copyright © 2026. King Spry. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy