A recent decision from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania provides important guidance for school districts on navigating Title IX obligations, particularly in the context of special education. In Doe v. Methacton Sch. Dist., the Court dismissed the Plaintiffs’ Title IX harassment claims but allowed their Title IX retaliation claim to proceed.
Background in the Case
In Methacton, a minor student, mother, and father (“Plaintiffs”) sued Methacton School District (“District”) after the student was subject to bullying and sexual harassment at school. The Methacton decision also discusses special education issues, as the student qualified for and received special education services through an Individualized Education Plan (IEP).
Alleged Harassment & Bullying
The student’s IEP provided her access to an emotional support classroom, which another student and aide were also assigned to. During November and December of 2022, the student was left unsupervised with the aide, who allegedly pursued an inappropriate relationship with the student, grooming her. The student was also exposed to various instances of student-on-student bullying over the course of twenty one (21) months.
Reports & District Responses
On December 29, 2022, the mother reported the aide’s inappropriate behavior and student bullying to District officials, but she did not receive a response. On January 2, 2023, the mother emailed District officials, informing them that the student would not return to school until she was sure the student would not come into contact with the aide. The next day, the mother and District officials participated in a Zoom call to discuss the mother’s reports.
Procedural Issues
Despite the District’s conversations with the mother, the District did not (1) inform the Plaintiffs of the student’s rights under Title IX, (2) initiate a Title IX investigation, or (3) advise the parents of supportive measures available to the student. In fact, the District did not commence a formal Title IX investigation until August of 2023, and it ignored the mother’s request for education records.
Reduction in Educational Services
In January of 2023, the District proposed virtual instruction for the student without offering supportive measures for in-person programming. The student’s IEP was revised again for full virtual programming. Eventually, the District stopped implementing the student’s IEP and failed to monitor her progress.
Complaints
The parents filed complaints with the Pennsylvania Department of Education, the Office for Dispute Resolution, and the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission. Relevant here, the Plaintiffs also filed a complaint against the District in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, alleging harassment and retaliation under Title IX. The District filed a motion to dismiss counts 1-4 of the complaint, which the Court granted in part and denied in part, as discussed below.
Count I: Violation of Title IX
Count I was dismissed because Plaintiffs’ failed to establish all of the elements of a Title IX claim. A Title IX claim must establish that: (1) the defendant receives federal funding; (2) sexual harassment occurred; (3) the harassment occurred under circumstances where the defendant had substantial control over the harasser and the context; (4) the defendant had actual knowledge of the harassment; (5) the defendant was “deliberately indifferent”; and (6) the harassment was “so severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive” that it deprived the victim of educational opportunities.
First, the Court addressed the allegations of student-on-student harassment. It concluded that the Plaintiffs did not allege conduct that was sufficiently “severe or pervasive.” Although sexual comments were directed towards the student, these comments took place over the course of twenty-one (21) months. Thus, the “sporadic and isolated” nature of the comments did not satisfy element six (6). Next, the Court addressed the allegations of harassment by the student aide. It held that the aide’s comment to the student (i.e., “I am trying to touch your wenis”) was “pervasive,” satisfying element six (6).
However, the Court concluded that the District did not act with “deliberate indifference” once it was put on notice of the aide’s conduct, because the District participated in a Zoom call with the mother, assured the mother that it was safe for the student to return to school, reported the abuse to Child and Youth, and Children and Youth interviewed the student.
Despite the District’s delayed Title IX procedures, failure to inform the Plaintiffs of the student’s rights under Title IX, and failure to advise the parents of supportive measures, these actions did not establish “deliberate indifference.” The Court noted that these are allegations of “procedural defects” with the District’s investigation. Thus, a plaintiff’s dissatisfaction with how a school district conducts its investigations does not establish “deliberate indifference.”
Count II: Retaliation in Violation of Title IX
Count II will proceed because the Plaintiffs established all of the elements of a retaliation claim. A retaliation claim must show that (1) the plaintiff engaged in a protected activity, (2) the plaintiff suffered an adverse action, and (3) there was a causal connection.
Here, there was no dispute that the Plaintiffs engaged in a protected activity. Rather, the District contended that the Plaintiffs did not allege an adverse action and/or that they failed to establish a causal connection. The Court rejected the District’s arguments, concluding that the Plaintiffs suffered adverse action due to the District:
- Delaying IEP meetings;
- Making inappropriate changes to the student’s IEP;
- Moving the student to an inferior virtual program;
- Reducing the student’s special education services;
- Attempting to coerce the mother into signing a waiver of the student’s rights;
- Dismissing the formal Title IX complaint; and
- Imposing restrictions on the use of compensatory education funds.
Lastly, there was a causal connection between the protected activity and adverse action, because the District exhibited a pattern of antagonism towards the student and there was a “strong temporal proximity” between the parents’ reports and the District’s actions. Therefore, the Plaintiffs’ retaliation claim will proceed.
Counts III and IV: Section 1983 Enforcement
Counts III and IV seek Section 1983 Enforcement of Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause. Section 1983 is a federal law that allows individuals to sue for violations of their constitutional rights. The Court dismissed Count III because “[Section] 1983 does not offer a route to recover for alleged violations of Title IX.” It also dismissed Count IV because the Plaintiffs did not establish all elements of their Title IX claim.
Bottom Line for Schools
Methacton demonstrates the high bar Plaintiffs face to establish Title IX claims. Plaintiffs must establish six (6) elements, including that the defendant was “deliberately indifferent” to the alleged harassment. The Court highlighted that “[t]he standards for deliberate indifference impose a ‘significant burden on a Plaintiff and as such these claims “rarely proceed beyond a motion to dismiss.”’” Methacton also clarifies that procedural defects are not enough to meet this element. Even so, school districts must ensure strict compliance with Title IX procedures, including reporting, investigations, and supportive measures.
Regular training of staff and administrative personnel in Title IX requirements is the best antidote to protect schools from liability.
School Law Bullets are a publication of KingSpry’s Education Law Practice Group. They are meant to be informational and do not constitute legal advice. If your school has a question, please consult your legal counsel or one of the Education attorneys at KingSpry.





