• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
KingSpry Logo

King, Spry, Herman, Freund & Faul, LLC.

Attorneys & Counselors

  • 610-332-0390
  • Pay My Bill (Retainer Only)
  • Pay My Bill (All Other Invoices)
  • About
    • About Us
    • Commitment to the Community
    • Firm History
    • Career Opportunities At KingSpry
    • Directions
  • Practices
    • Adoption / ART Law
    • Affordable Housing Law
    • Bankruptcy Law
    • Business Law
    • Education Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Planning / Administration
    • Family Law
    • Investigations and Compliance Services
    • Litigation
    • Local Taxation and Assessment
    • Municipal Law
    • Public Finance
    • Real Estate Law
    • Special Education Law
  • Team
  • Greyfriars
  • News
    • News
    • Articles
  • Podcasts
    • Landmarks Podcasts
    • Legal Lunch Room Podcasts
  • Review
  • Contact

Unanimous Supreme Court Issues Narrow Decision Regarding Government Limits on Religious Discrimination by Government Contractors

Posted on June 18th, 2021
by Rebecca A. Young

The Fulton v. City of Philadelphia case has been followed by many, including those with an interest in foster care, LBGT rights and religious freedoms. 

The decision upheld the right of Catholic Social Services (“CSS”) to refuse to certify same-sex and unmarried couples as foster parents, as certifying such couples would violate the religious beliefs of the Catholic Church. 

The decision also highlighted the need for foster parents and noted the importance of the government interests in providing safe homes for children. 

The Court held that the City’s requirement that all foster agencies agree to certify gay couples violated the First Amendment of the Constitution with regard to the free exercise of religion. The decision did not establish any new legal standards and was based on specific terms in the City’s contract that were added in 2018 after the City Council received a complaint about a different agency (not CSS).

The decision did not address any of the broad constitutional issues that were raised and argued by the many parties interested in this case.  Six of the nine justices participated in issuing separate opinions stating why and how the existing standard for review of governmental restrictions on discrimination by religious entities should have been reviewed and changed. 

Under existing precedent, government actions are constitutional if they are neutral laws that apply to everyone.  Here, the Court determined that the City’s contract allowed for individual exemptions from the non-discrimination requirement that could be granted at the sole discretion of the Commissioner.  Because the contract allowed for individual exemptions, the non-discrimination requirement was subject to strict scrutiny – the City had to establish that it could not meet its interest in providing foster homes in a manner that would not place a burden on CSS’s religious freedoms.  The City did not document that granting an exemption to CSS would prevent it from providing foster care services.  Therefore, imposing the non-discrimination requirement violated CSS’s constitutional right to free exercise of religion.

Like most Supreme Court decisions, the legal analysis discusses issues that are not central to the final decision.  A portion of interest to foster care providers is the discussion whether the provision of foster care is a “public accommodation.”  A public accommodation is a good or service that is made available to the public; it is unlawful to discriminate in the provision of public accommodations – for example, to discriminate on the basis of race in the provision of housing. 

The Court determined that certification as a foster parent is not made available to the general public.  The process to become certified to provide foster care requires extensive evaluation of the individual’s physical and mental health, a home study, background checks and other inquiries into the applicant’s relationships.  Therefore, the provision of foster care services is not a public accommodation. 

What it Means

Governments can enforce non-discrimination laws when they are created and enforced uniformly, even if those laws affect religious entities.  However, they cannot target religious entities and their beliefs in a way that violates the right to free exercise of religion.  Therefore, individual rights against discrimination are preserved under this decision.  The City’s anti-discrimination ordinance protection of LGBT rights remains intact and enforceable.

Children that cannot live with their birth parents need foster parents.  Fostering is a calling and meeting each child’s individual needs and ensuring their safety are the key factors in identifying foster parents. 

heARTbeat is a publication of KingSpry’s Adoption Law and Assisted Reproductive Technology Law Practice Group. It is meant to be informational and does not constitute legal advice.

Primary Sidebar

Contact Us

Contacting any of the attorneys at KingSpry by e-mail or other means does not create an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, you should not send confidential information through this form or by e-mail. Unless and until you speak with one of our attorneys and an attorney-client relationship is formally established by that attorney's agreement to represent you, you should not send us confidential information. If you are not currently a client of King, Spry, Herman, Freund & Faul, LLC, your e-mail is not considered confidential.

From Our Articles

A green stylized logo with the letters "K" and "S" combined within a green square. The "K," formed by abstract shapes, is to the left while the conventional "S" on the right balances it perfectly. Ideal for your homepage branding.

New York Law Grants Employees Access to their Personnel Records

November 10, 2026

On September 9, New York Governor Kathy Hochul signed Senate Bill No. 3460 into law, amending New York’s labor

A green stylized logo with the letters "K" and "S" combined within a green square. The "K," formed by abstract shapes, is to the left while the conventional "S" on the right balances it perfectly. Ideal for your homepage branding.

Small, Yet BIG Changes to the Municipalities Planning Code

November 3, 2026

On October 8, 2026, Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro signed Act 58 of 2026 into law. Act 58 amends the

Footer

King Spry White Logo

Quick Link

About KingSpry Commitment to the Community Firm History Career Opportunities at KingSpry Directions

Practice Areas

Adoption / ART Law Affordable Housing Law Bankruptcy Law Business Law Education Law Employment Law Estate Planning / Administration Family Law
Investigations and Compliance Services Litigation Local Taxation and Assessment Municipal Law Public Finance Real Estate Law Special Education Law

Contact

phone

610-332-0390

email

contact@kingspry.com

location

1 West Broad Street. Suite 700 Bethlehem, PA 18018

location

American Heritage Building. 4400 Walbert Avenue Allentown, PA 18104

Facebook Youtube LinkedIn

Pay My Bill (Retainer Only) Pay My Bill (All Other Invoices)

Copyright © 2026. King Spry. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy