On May 19, 2026, the PA Supreme Court issued its ruling in Downingtown Area Sch. Dist. v. Chester County Bd. of Assessment Appeals, which examines school districts’ implementation and application of real estate assessment appeal policies with a monetary threshold for selecting properties to appeal and the application of those policies.
Facts in the Case
The Downingtown Area School District (the “District”) adopted a policy to pursue appeals of properties only if it may result in additional tax revenues of at least $10,000 per year in the aggregate by the applicable taxing districts. The policy does not consider the type or nature of a property (e.g., commercial, residential, agricultural, industrial) when determining whether the property may be underassessed and subject to an appeal. Since the policy’s effective date in 2012, District appeals have included properties classified as industrial, farm, commercial, residential, and apartment complexes.
For the 2020 tax year, the District’s contracted consultant identified fifteen appealable parcels that met the monetary threshold. In June 2019, Marchwood Apartments (the “Taxpayer”) purchased an apartment complex consisting of two parcels operating as a single economic unit (the “subject property”). Thereafter, the District added the subject property to its list of identified properties because, based on the purchase price, an appeal of the property’s assessment was highly likely to yield tax revenues over the monetary threshold.
The District appealed sixteen assessments, including the subject property, none of which was a single-family home. The trial court concluded that the District’s policy used a purely economic approach that did not discriminate based on property type, and that residential, commercial, apartment complexes, and industrial properties had all been appealed under it since its inception. The Taxpayer appealed the trial court decision to the Commonwealth Court.
The Commonwealth Court reversed the trial court, finding that the District’s policy – which was recognized as constitutional on its face – was nevertheless implemented in an arbitrary manner, inasmuch as they chose 15 properties without explanation and added the subject property without identification by the consultant, despite the fact that other properties satisfied the monetary threshold.
The District appealed to the Supreme Court, which considered the following issues:
- Did the Commonwealth Court err by holding that the District must appeal “all potentially underassessed properties” to comply with the Uniformity Clause?
- Did the Commonwealth Court err by holding that the District’s implementation of its appeal policy was arbitrary on the present record?
The Opinion
The Supreme Court’s 4-3 decision vacated the Commonwealth Court’s ruling, ultimately determining that no violations of the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution or the Uniformity Clause of the Pennsylvania Constitution occurred.
Justice Mundy noted in the majority opinion: “the Uniformity Clause prohibits intentional or systematic differential treatment of subclasses of property, whether the governmental conduct is ‘wrongful’ or not…But that does not mean the Uniformity Clause imports the concept of ‘disparate impact’ wholesale from civil rights law and applies it the same way…The Uniformity Clause focuses on purposeful differential treatment, not differential impact. A neutral, systematic treatment of all properties might affect different properties differently due to their economic value, which varies as the economy and market fluctuate. To violate the Uniformity Clause, the classification would have to be drawn in a way that indicates the members of one class will be treated differently regardless of such changes, which did not occur here.”
The Supreme Court held that the monetary threshold, in and of itself, does not violate the Uniformity Clause. The Court explained that when a taxing district’s policy does not create a prohibited subclass of properties, “it tends to enhance uniformity by selecting for appeal the properties whose assessments are the most nonuniform in terms of their tax-liability deficit.” The Court, referencing the Brief for Amici Curiae filed by KingSpry on behalf of Easton Area School District & Salisbury Township School District, noted that by eliminating those outlier assessments, it “enhances fairness to the remaining taxpayers who would otherwise need to pay more of the cost of government than their proportionate share” as taxing district would be constrained to raise their millage rates.
Additionally, the Supreme Court held that the District’s policy was not applied and carried out in an arbitrary or discriminatory manner. The Court acknowledged that requiring any taxing district that decides to use a monetary threshold to appeal all properties that satisfy the threshold or none at all creates “an unreasonable result.”
The Court reasoned that taxing districts are granted discretion to decide whether to expend public funds to appeal a particular property, considering the risks and maximizing potential rewards of the appeal. And the Court determined that the policy was not invalid solely because it had led to fewer appeals of residential properties. The Court recognized that market fluctuations could drive up single-family home values, making it just as practical for a taxing district to appeal those properties based on the monetary threshold. In its application, residential properties were not systematically excluded from the policy, as reasonable calculations were made in accordance with the monetary threshold.
Bottom Line for Schools
A school district’s adoption of a “facially neutral” monetary threshold for initiating tax assessment appeals – such as only appealing those properties underassessed to such an extent as to reasonably generate an additional $10,000 in new school district real estate tax – is permissible under the Equal Protection Clause and Uniformity Clause. The policy itself cannot create a subclass of properties defined by an impermissible characteristic, specifically type, use, neighborhood, and/or residency status.
Additionally, school districts should implement practices in compliance with their own policies to ensure equal treatment of all properties when filing district tax assessment appeals to withstand uniformity challenges.
The Education Law team at KingSpry has successfully navigated tax assessment appeals for various school districts for decades. School officials with questions about tax assessment should contact their local legal counsel or a member of the Local Taxation and Assessment Law Practice Group at KingSpry.





