What Happened at Cornell University: Title IX Not a Toothless Tiger
Posted on October 16th, 2026
by Brian J. Taylor
Since mid-September, Cornell University (Cornell) has been at the center of major media and public scrutiny regarding its handling of an alleged sexual assault that occurred at its Chi Phi fraternity house in October 2024.
Seven members of fraternity house allegedly committed the assault on the plaintiff (Jane Doe) who was a 20 year old female at the time. She has indicated that she was visibly intoxicated and impaired at the time by alcohol and drugs.
What happened at Cornell?
On September 16, 2026, Jane Doe filed a civil lawsuit in the state of New York against Cornell University; the Chi Phi fraternity at which the alleged assault took place and seven members who allegedly took part; the Alpha Beta House sorority of which Jane Doe was a member; and Moonies bar at which she was served alcohol despite being underage and allegedly impaired.
Following the filing of Jane Doe’s civil lawsuit in late September 2026 the New York district attorney (DA), Matthew Van Houten, reopened the criminal case, that in 2024 had been closed without charges within weeks of Jane Doe’s report to Cornell Campus police of the alleged gang rape at the fraternity.
In response, New York Governor Kathy Hochul removed Van Houten and appointed New York Attorney General, Letitia James, as special prosecutor in the case. At the same time Cornell has hired former U.S. Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates to conduct an independent review of how Cornell handles and investigates sexual harassment, sexual assault, and related misconduct.
In the media and public, scrutiny has focused on the Title IX federal statute prohibiting sex-based discrimination and sex-based harassment with confusion between it and what criminal prosecution requires. Some have suggested that Title IX lacks the teeth to protect victims of sexual assault. Nothing could be further from the truth.
Clearly, misinformation and misunderstandings in the media and by the public believing that a Title IX investigation is equivalent to a criminal investigation created many issues:
(1) Title IX has confidentiality and privacy requirements that a criminal prosecution does not have; thus, giving the perception of secrecy and lack of transparency on the part of Cornell. However, those very confidentiality and privacy provisions break down barriers that would otherwise see complainants refusing to come forward.
(2) Title IX, while not providing a definition of “consent,” through court cases and the Office of Civil Rights (OCR) resolutions, recommends a definition where intoxication/incapacitation make a person incapable of giving consent, whether or not the drugs and/or alcohol were taken voluntarily. The New York state law definition takes into consideration the voluntary taking of drugs and/or alcohol as a factor in determining consent.
(3) A general misunderstanding that the sanctions and remedies afforded a school under Title IX and through its policies and student code of conduct are the same, or should be the same, as that provided if the defendants are prosecuted and found guilty under criminal law.
At Cornell, one of the largest controversies reported in the media is the outrage over several of the defendants receiving as their sole sanction, or as part of other sanctions, the assignment to write an essay regarding what they learned from their misconduct. Cornell denies this to be true, but to many following the Cornell matter, the writing of essays is outrageous given the serious nature of the gang rape allegations.
(4) The misunderstanding that the grievance process required by Title IX is inferior to a criminal investigation. Title IX requires a grievance process that is detailed, free from bias and conflict of interest, that allows parties to review all evidence and the investigation report, that at the university level requires a live hearing to determine responsibility, and that provides an appeal process. Parties can also file a complaint with the federal OCR (see information later in this article).
The Title IX grievance process is no less thorough in many respects than a criminal investigation. It is a different process with a different purpose.
(5) Another major misunderstanding among the media and public and source of much of the controversy is the role of campus police and law enforcement.
Often school policies do not clearly and definitively define the role campus police and law enforcement play in a Title IX investigation and what their role is in a parallel criminal investigation. Here the major controversy seems to focus on what information was exchanged between campus police and the District Attorneys and when.
(6) The credibility and memory of sexual assault victims and how their memories can change over time has created criticism, along with threats of violence, toward Jane Doe. Media reports suggest that Jane Doe’s memory and recollection of events have changed since the alleged assault.
None of these misunderstandings or this misinformation mean that either process, Title IX or the criminal justice system, is inherently problematic. They do highlight that Cornell’s discrimination and harassment policies possibly need to be reviewed and strengthened. Well-defined policies need to clearly define the role of the university, its campus police, and law enforcement and how they will cooperate when allegations of misconduct arise, particularly sexual violence.
What We Can Learn from the Jane Doe Case
If schools learn anything from the Cornell University Jane Doe civil lawsuit, it should be that BOTH the federal Title IX civil rights statute and state criminal justice processes have an important role to play in protecting individuals from sex-based discrimination and sex-based harassment, especially in such a serious situation as a gang rape allegation. Both processes are separate, but clearly must closely coordinate with each other.
The federal Office for Civil Rights (OCR) currently pursues sexual violence cases far less often than it did at one time.
A review of recent government files indicates that OCR has opened fewer than 10 cases of sexual violence since its March 2025 layoffs compared with dozens a year before and has reached no voluntary resolution agreements in sexual violence cases since January 2025 after 23 in 2024. However, over the same period, OCR opened 50 investigations involving transgender students’ participation in athletics and access to facilities.
What this data shows is that OCR may not be the agency to help institutions manage Title IX sexual violence in the short-term.
Whatever the federal priorities are, the Cornell case demonstrates that a school’s obligations under Title IX and to cooperate with criminal investigations have not shrunk.
Every school receiving federal funds is still bound to stop, prevent, and remedy Title IX sex-based discrimination and harassment, including sexual violence. OCR may not currently be the watchdog it once was, but schools can still find themselves under scrutiny from victims, courts, and the press.
Key Takeaways for Colleges and Universities
Title IX and the criminal justice system were meant to run in parallel. One does not replace the other. At Cornell University, both processes took place, but the biggest failure appears to be lack of communication and coordination between the Title IX process the University conducted and the criminal investigation by law enforcement.
No single investigator or decision-maker appears from media reports to have seen all the information, despite there having been an almost eight-month Title IX investigation, with at least 32 witnesses interviewed, that culminated in a 99-page determination report.
While the Cornell case may take some time to resolve, institutions can move forward now in protecting themselves and their institutions from what Cornell is experiencing. They can strengthen their current Title IX policies and practices to ensure they serve their important function of stopping, preventing, and remedying sex-based discrimination and harassment, including sexual violence, as an important civil right of every individual at a federally funded school or college.
Attorney Taylor is a partner with KingSpry, where he chairs KingSpry’s Investigations and Compliance Services Team. He is a certified Title IX investigator through SUNY’s Student Conduct Institute and regularly conducts internal investigations for clients on Title IX matters, Employment discrimination, harassment, retaliation and instances of workplace misconduct. Dr. Brennan assists KingSpry’s Investigations and Compliance Services Team on Title VI, Title VII, Title IX, and other investigation matters. Dr. Brennan has served as Title IX investigator, decision-maker, appeal decision-maker, and informal resolution facilitator, and is certified in each of those roles by the Association of Title IX Administrators (ATIXA). She is also certified in Title VI Compliance. Dr. Brennan is a former K-12 Pennsylvania educator, having served in many roles from teacher to superintendent and Intermediate Unit Executive Director for 36 years, retiring in 2019. She brings an educator’s view and insights into the complex world of investigations and compliance.
What Happened at Cornell University: Title IX Not a Toothless Tiger
Posted on October 16th, 2026
by Brian J. Taylor
Since mid-September, Cornell University (Cornell) has been at the center of major media and public scrutiny regarding its handling of an alleged sexual assault that occurred at its Chi Phi fraternity house in October 2024.
Seven members of fraternity house allegedly committed the assault on the plaintiff (Jane Doe) who was a 20 year old female at the time. She has indicated that she was visibly intoxicated and impaired at the time by alcohol and drugs.
What happened at Cornell?
On September 16, 2026, Jane Doe filed a civil lawsuit in the state of New York against Cornell University; the Chi Phi fraternity at which the alleged assault took place and seven members who allegedly took part; the Alpha Beta House sorority of which Jane Doe was a member; and Moonies bar at which she was served alcohol despite being underage and allegedly impaired.
Following the filing of Jane Doe’s civil lawsuit in late September 2026 the New York district attorney (DA), Matthew Van Houten, reopened the criminal case, that in 2024 had been closed without charges within weeks of Jane Doe’s report to Cornell Campus police of the alleged gang rape at the fraternity.
In response, New York Governor Kathy Hochul removed Van Houten and appointed New York Attorney General, Letitia James, as special prosecutor in the case. At the same time Cornell has hired former U.S. Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates to conduct an independent review of how Cornell handles and investigates sexual harassment, sexual assault, and related misconduct.
In the media and public, scrutiny has focused on the Title IX federal statute prohibiting sex-based discrimination and sex-based harassment with confusion between it and what criminal prosecution requires. Some have suggested that Title IX lacks the teeth to protect victims of sexual assault. Nothing could be further from the truth.
Clearly, misinformation and misunderstandings in the media and by the public believing that a Title IX investigation is equivalent to a criminal investigation created many issues:
(1) Title IX has confidentiality and privacy requirements that a criminal prosecution does not have; thus, giving the perception of secrecy and lack of transparency on the part of Cornell. However, those very confidentiality and privacy provisions break down barriers that would otherwise see complainants refusing to come forward.
(2) Title IX, while not providing a definition of “consent,” through court cases and the Office of Civil Rights (OCR) resolutions, recommends a definition where intoxication/incapacitation make a person incapable of giving consent, whether or not the drugs and/or alcohol were taken voluntarily. The New York state law definition takes into consideration the voluntary taking of drugs and/or alcohol as a factor in determining consent.
(3) A general misunderstanding that the sanctions and remedies afforded a school under Title IX and through its policies and student code of conduct are the same, or should be the same, as that provided if the defendants are prosecuted and found guilty under criminal law.
At Cornell, one of the largest controversies reported in the media is the outrage over several of the defendants receiving as their sole sanction, or as part of other sanctions, the assignment to write an essay regarding what they learned from their misconduct. Cornell denies this to be true, but to many following the Cornell matter, the writing of essays is outrageous given the serious nature of the gang rape allegations.
(4) The misunderstanding that the grievance process required by Title IX is inferior to a criminal investigation. Title IX requires a grievance process that is detailed, free from bias and conflict of interest, that allows parties to review all evidence and the investigation report, that at the university level requires a live hearing to determine responsibility, and that provides an appeal process. Parties can also file a complaint with the federal OCR (see information later in this article).
The Title IX grievance process is no less thorough in many respects than a criminal investigation. It is a different process with a different purpose.
(5) Another major misunderstanding among the media and public and source of much of the controversy is the role of campus police and law enforcement.
Often school policies do not clearly and definitively define the role campus police and law enforcement play in a Title IX investigation and what their role is in a parallel criminal investigation. Here the major controversy seems to focus on what information was exchanged between campus police and the District Attorneys and when.
(6) The credibility and memory of sexual assault victims and how their memories can change over time has created criticism, along with threats of violence, toward Jane Doe. Media reports suggest that Jane Doe’s memory and recollection of events have changed since the alleged assault.
None of these misunderstandings or this misinformation mean that either process, Title IX or the criminal justice system, is inherently problematic. They do highlight that Cornell’s discrimination and harassment policies possibly need to be reviewed and strengthened. Well-defined policies need to clearly define the role of the university, its campus police, and law enforcement and how they will cooperate when allegations of misconduct arise, particularly sexual violence.
What We Can Learn from the Jane Doe Case
If schools learn anything from the Cornell University Jane Doe civil lawsuit, it should be that BOTH the federal Title IX civil rights statute and state criminal justice processes have an important role to play in protecting individuals from sex-based discrimination and sex-based harassment, especially in such a serious situation as a gang rape allegation. Both processes are separate, but clearly must closely coordinate with each other.
The federal Office for Civil Rights (OCR) currently pursues sexual violence cases far less often than it did at one time.
A review of recent government files indicates that OCR has opened fewer than 10 cases of sexual violence since its March 2025 layoffs compared with dozens a year before and has reached no voluntary resolution agreements in sexual violence cases since January 2025 after 23 in 2024. However, over the same period, OCR opened 50 investigations involving transgender students’ participation in athletics and access to facilities.
What this data shows is that OCR may not be the agency to help institutions manage Title IX sexual violence in the short-term.
Whatever the federal priorities are, the Cornell case demonstrates that a school’s obligations under Title IX and to cooperate with criminal investigations have not shrunk.
Every school receiving federal funds is still bound to stop, prevent, and remedy Title IX sex-based discrimination and harassment, including sexual violence. OCR may not currently be the watchdog it once was, but schools can still find themselves under scrutiny from victims, courts, and the press.
Key Takeaways for Colleges and Universities
Title IX and the criminal justice system were meant to run in parallel. One does not replace the other. At Cornell University, both processes took place, but the biggest failure appears to be lack of communication and coordination between the Title IX process the University conducted and the criminal investigation by law enforcement.
No single investigator or decision-maker appears from media reports to have seen all the information, despite there having been an almost eight-month Title IX investigation, with at least 32 witnesses interviewed, that culminated in a 99-page determination report.
While the Cornell case may take some time to resolve, institutions can move forward now in protecting themselves and their institutions from what Cornell is experiencing. They can strengthen their current Title IX policies and practices to ensure they serve their important function of stopping, preventing, and remedying sex-based discrimination and harassment, including sexual violence, as an important civil right of every individual at a federally funded school or college.
If you have any questions, please consult with your legal counsel or one of the Investigation and Compliance Services attorneys at KingSpry.
About the Authors
Attorney Taylor is a partner with KingSpry, where he chairs KingSpry’s Investigations and Compliance Services Team. He is a certified Title IX investigator through SUNY’s Student Conduct Institute and regularly conducts internal investigations for clients on Title IX matters, Employment discrimination, harassment, retaliation and instances of workplace misconduct. Dr. Brennan assists KingSpry’s Investigations and Compliance Services Team on Title VI, Title VII, Title IX, and other investigation matters. Dr. Brennan has served as Title IX investigator, decision-maker, appeal decision-maker, and informal resolution facilitator, and is certified in each of those roles by the Association of Title IX Administrators (ATIXA). She is also certified in Title VI Compliance. Dr. Brennan is a former K-12 Pennsylvania educator, having served in many roles from teacher to superintendent and Intermediate Unit Executive Director for 36 years, retiring in 2019. She brings an educator’s view and insights into the complex world of investigations and compliance.