• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
KingSpry Logo

King, Spry, Herman, Freund & Faul, LLC.

Attorneys & Counselors

  • 610-332-0390
  • Pay My Bill (Retainer Only)
  • Pay My Bill (All Other Invoices)
  • About
    • About Us
    • Commitment to the Community
    • Firm History
    • Career Opportunities At KingSpry
    • Directions
  • Practices
    • Adoption / ART Law
    • Affordable Housing Law
    • Bankruptcy Law
    • Business Law
    • Education Law
    • Employment Law
    • Estate Planning / Administration
    • Family Law
    • Investigations and Compliance Services
    • Litigation
    • Local Taxation and Assessment
    • Municipal Law
    • Public Finance
    • Real Estate Law
    • Special Education Law
  • Team
  • Greyfriars
  • News
    • News
    • Articles
  • Podcasts
    • Landmarks Podcasts
    • Legal Lunch Room Podcasts
  • Review
  • Contact

South Hanover’s Appointment of Board Member Did Not Violate Sunshine Act

Posted on April 10th, 2023
by John E. Freund, III

A Pennsylvania appeals court has ruled that the South Hanover Township Board of Supervisors did not violate the Sunshine Act when it appointed an individual to fill a vacancy where board members have informed discussions about who to approve.

The court’s opinion offers guidance to public school boards that may find themselves dealing with similar issues. For example, the court held that informal discussions about appointments for elected offices do not need to occur at open meetings and that official action taken at a later meeting cures a prior Sunshine Act violation.

Read more about Shipman v. South Hanover Township Board of Supervisors et al., No. 401 C.D. 2022 (Commw. Ct. Feb. 17, 2023, unpublished opinion.)

Resident Sues Over Appointment of Elected Official

On Nov. 23, 2021, a supervisor resigned from the South Hanover Township Board of Supervisors. The board announced it would accept letters of interest from township residents until the end of the year.

Henry Shipman submitted a letter of interest less than a week later. However, the board appointed Jack Studer to fill the position at its Dec. 14 public meeting following an executive session and without public deliberation over the candidates. When Shipman questioned the selection process, the board allegedly told him that the four supervisors had discussed and made the selection in informal telephone calls.

Ultimately, Shipman sued the board, alleging it violated the Sunshine Act when it appointed Studer. The Dauphin County Court of Common Pleas dismissed the complaint with prejudice after considering the board’s preliminary objections.

Public Vote Cured Any Violation

Shipman appealed, and the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court agreed with the trial court’s decision. The appeals court concluded that Shipman failed to state a cause of action under the Sunshine Act because even though the deliberations did not occur publicly, the voting did.

On Jan. 3, 2022, South Hanover had published its agenda for a reorganization meeting and noted its proposal to appoint someone to fill the vacant position. The board did not request letters of interest and identified Studer as the only person to appoint. A public vote was held for Studer.

The court explained that “official action taken at a later, open meeting cures a prior violation of the Sunshine Act.”

The court also said the board did not violate the open meetings law by engaging in informal phone conversations about filling the vacancy in advance. 

“Pennsylvania courts have concluded that straw votes, informal discussions, and information-gathering are not necessarily official actions that must take place at open meetings under the Sunshine Act,” the opinion said. 

Bottom Line for Schools

Public school boards should ensure that they fill vacancies in elected offices and conduct other official business in strict accordance with Pennsylvania law. Although the court concluded that informal discussions are not necessarily official actions that must take place at an open meeting, the law remains that boards cannot “meet” in private to discuss filling a vacancy for an elected office.

Questions about the process of filling board vacancies should be directed to the board solicitor or a member of the KingSpry Education Law Practice Group. 

Primary Sidebar

Contact Us

Contacting any of the attorneys at KingSpry by e-mail or other means does not create an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, you should not send confidential information through this form or by e-mail. Unless and until you speak with one of our attorneys and an attorney-client relationship is formally established by that attorney's agreement to represent you, you should not send us confidential information. If you are not currently a client of King, Spry, Herman, Freund & Faul, LLC, your e-mail is not considered confidential.

From Our Articles

A green stylized logo with the letters "K" and "S" combined within a green square. The "K," formed by abstract shapes, is to the left while the conventional "S" on the right balances it perfectly. Ideal for your homepage branding.

Pennsylvania’s Act 87 of 2026: Expanded Mandated Reporting Obligations

November 20, 2026

Pennsylvania’s Child Protective Services Law (CPSL) continues to evolve in response to emerging concerns

A green stylized logo with the letters "K" and "S" combined within a green square. The "K," formed by abstract shapes, is to the left while the conventional "S" on the right balances it perfectly. Ideal for your homepage branding.

Welcome News for PA Government & Agencies: Act 114 Prohibits Certain Terms in Procurement Contracts

November 18, 2026

On October 22, 2026, Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro signed Act 114 of 2026 into law, prohibiting certain

Footer

King Spry White Logo

Quick Link

About KingSpry Commitment to the Community Firm History Career Opportunities at KingSpry Directions

Practice Areas

Adoption / ART Law Affordable Housing Law Bankruptcy Law Business Law Education Law Employment Law Estate Planning / Administration Family Law
Investigations and Compliance Services Litigation Local Taxation and Assessment Municipal Law Public Finance Real Estate Law Special Education Law

Contact

phone

610-332-0390

email

contact@kingspry.com

location

1 West Broad Street. Suite 700 Bethlehem, PA 18018

location

American Heritage Building. 4400 Walbert Avenue Allentown, PA 18104

Facebook Youtube LinkedIn

Pay My Bill (Retainer Only) Pay My Bill (All Other Invoices)

Copyright © 2026. King Spry. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy