Students and their Parents bear the burden of showing by a preponderance of the evidence that a School District violated its Child Find obligation under Section 504. Absent sufficient evidence of the same and where the District acted reasonably, liability does not attach.
Overview of Prior Third Circuit Decision
Back in 2024, the Third Circuit ruled in B.S.M. v. Upper Darby School District, that the rights of children with disabilities under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 are distinct from their rights under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). Stated differently, a school’s Child Find obligations may require evaluation under Section 504 even if a student was evaluated and determined to be ineligible under the IDEA. However, the Third Circuit did not go so far as to perform an analysis under Section 504 to determine whether the District violated its Child Find obligations. Rather, this factual question was remanded to the lower court.
Remand to Eastern District
On remand, the lower court found no violation of Section 504 and no basis to award additional compensatory education. B.S.M. v. Upper Darby Sch. Dist., No. 21-5164 (E.D. Pa. 2025). Plaintiffs continued to argue that the District violated Child Find under Section 504 when it failed to perform a comprehensive evaluation of Student until her Fourth grade year, despite parental request for the same during Kindergarten. They further contend that in Second grade, the District should have considered whether Student had a 504 eligible disability given that a community mental health provider diagnosed Student with depressive disorder. Interestingly, the Court found that Parent never communicated this diagnosis to the District as she could not substantiate when or how she conveyed this information and lacked any documentation of her doing so.
The Eastern District of Pennsylvania concluded that in both instances – Kindergarten and Fourth Grade – when Parent requested a full psychoeducational evaluation, the District responded in a reasonable timeframe with an appropriate range of assessment tools. In Kindergarten, despite being only a few months into her school career, the District reasonably evaluated Student for speech/language concerns as this was the motivating factor behind Parent’s request. The District further indicated that cognitive and academic achievement testing was unnecessary at this time as Student was performing sufficiently on classroom-based assessments and standardized testing.
Again, in Fourth grade, Parents requested the District develop a Section 504 plan because Student was a “sensitive, dramatic child”. The District promptly agreed to conduct a comprehensive evaluation, assessing Student’s cognitive, academic, ad social-emotional functioning. However, Parent did not make the District aware of Student’s new mental health diagnosis of DMDD at this time and thus, it was not considered for purposes of the evaluation. Jointly, schooling was offered remotely as a result of the pandemic thus, the District was not observing any struggles attributable to her diagnosis and did not have reason to believe that Student qualified as disabled under Section 504. Although Student began to experience emotional struggles in Second grade, evaluators noted that her emotional regulation was more evident at home and Parent did not share this information with the District.
Recent Appeal
Following this decision, Parents appealed to the Third Circuit. In April, the Third Circuit affirmed the lower court’s decision stating in part that Student insists that the multitude of behaviors she presents “fit the broad definition of [some unidentified] disability under Section 504”, however behavioral problems do not automatically “denote[] a disability or disorder.” Plaintiffs cannot maintain that the School District failed to identify a particular disability that she also fails to identify. Moreover, the record supports that Student’s varied academic performance did not give the District a reason to evaluate her prior to Fourth Grade. Furthermore, without knowledge of Student’s mental health diagnosis, the School District had no basis to suspect Student had a disability prior to learning of her DMDD diagnosis. B.S.M. v. Upper Darby Sch. Dist., No. 25-2071 (3d Cir. 2026).
Bottom Line for Schools
Schools do not necessarily violate Child Find by failing to identify a student as disabled at the “earliest possible moment.” Because some disabilities are difficult to diagnose, the school’s actions need only be reasonable based on its knowledge at the time. However, this case highlights the importance of information sharing between families and school districts.
Districts should be proactive in communications with Parents to ensure pertinent information is being shared and properly taken into consideration when determining next steps.





